On April 12, 2023 the Sugarcreek Borough Police were contacted by Probation and Parole for the report of an individual attempting to pass drug free urine.
Upon arrival Sugarcreek Borough Police officers spoke with the probation officer who advised that Michelle Cuttler, 38 of Centerville, PA, had passed a false urine that was not reading correctly. The probation officer then spoke with Michelle Cuttler who admitted to using methamphetamine.
The probation officer then had Cuttler provide a second urine sample. While attempting to pass a second urine sample a small plastic bottle dislodged from her person and fell to the floor. The probation officer then contacted police.
Michelle Cuttler was charged with the following:
Furnishing Drug Free Urine – Misdemeanor 3
Charges were filed through Magistrate Fish’s office.